Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: High School vs Allstars
cheer mom

Date:
High School vs Allstars


I would like to know how many allstar gyms support their girls (and boys) doing all stars and high school. As my daughter is getting into high school I am seeing this becoming an issue. Do gyms make you feel you have to choose, or are they ok with it as long as conflict is minimal if any at all? I am hearing about high schools telling girls they have to choose and will not take girls that do both. I am wondering if this is part of the reason we are seeing lower turn out to allstar tryouts (at least in No. CA). I would love to hear how it works in different cities especially So. CA as it seems they have an over abundance of girls doing all stars compared to us.


__________________
ACEDAD

Date:

Well, in Alabama, the all star gyms are fine with kids doing both. The schools aren't as encouraging. In fact, my daughter's high school prohibits doing both. We've talked to half a dozen colleges about her not getting any sideline experience and they told her to stick with all stars and forget high school if they wouldn't cooperate.

__________________
a mom

Date:

That is good to know Acedad because our high school prohibits it also. One girl tried to do both without telling the school but she was dropped off the team when the high school coach found out. We were told our daughter had to do high school in order for colleges to give her a chance but our high school is not competitive in cheerleading.

__________________
Jenete Kline

Date:

Here at Clayton Valley High School we have absolutely no problem with girls who do both. For the last 8 years, I've had multiple girls doing both programs (high school and all stars).

We've been extremely fortunate to have such an awesome relationship with PYRAMIDS that we've been able to pretty much work out any kinks in the scheduling conflicts that might arise.

Being part of Team PYRAMIDS has also made it a bit easier for the girls when it comes to competitions. We generally end up doing pretty much the same comps so besides making for an extremely long day for the kids that do both, the weekend committments are pretty much the same.

__________________
Pyramids Coach

Date:

What we have seen in the last couple of weeks with try-outs being held are a couple of different problems. The first problem is in order to be on a competitive all star team practices are mandatory. Of course you will have the occasional absences due to family and personal life problems, but for the most part if the team wants to be successful the kids won't miss practice. This is where the problem comes about with kids that would like to do high school as well as all stars. High school teams tend to go to camp, and have school related activities in August. Well that is the most crucial month for an all star team because that is when all of the coreography is taking place.

I have heard of some high schools not letting a child do both their high school team as well as an all star team. I don't think that it is a matter of the all star gyms not letting a child do both, but making sure the family understands that the child can not miss practices.

The nice thing about this situation is that Pyramids is offering a new team program that can work with the high school schedule as well the all star schedule. This program is called All Star Lite. This program is for those kids who really want to cheer for thier high school, that may or may not be competitive, but would also like to be on a competitive all star team. They only practice once a week for 2 hours, and the cost is lower than if the child were to do the full year program. They still compete at local competitions, and are apart of our all star tumlbing program. I think All Star Lite will make a lot of high school coaches happier because they can put their high school team as a top priority (as well as give that child an extra pracitce a week) and it will make families happier because they do not have to make a difficult decision in choosing which they would rather cheer for. If you have any questions or are interested about this program at Pyramids please feel free to call (925)685-3910, or e-mail the Pyramids program directors derick@cheergyms.com or jeff@cheergyms.com.

I hope this answers some questions to the high school and all star situation.

Angie Amo
Pyramids All Star AND Clayton Valley High School Coach

__________________
Angie

Date:

Jenete you read my mind. That is crazy that I was typing as you were posting, lol. Great minds think a like!!! :)

__________________
Nelson

Date:

Within cheergyms.com we have no issues with kids cheering at their HS's as well as within the All Star program. Come to think of it; what right do we have?

Perhaps I am stepping over the line here and I hope that I do not bruise any ego's, for it is not my intention. But, if I had a child I could not imagine anyone telling my child what they can and cannot do when it comes to their extra curricular activities. What right do they have? So long as my child is able to make all their commitments, I would tend to think that no one has a right to tell my child what they can and cannot do. Are they not allowed to play soccer, dance, join a club as well? If they can, why not join another cheer team?

A successful program will lay out the year for you and do all they can to stick to their schedule. This allows you to make other plans, have your child involved in other activities (not just cheerleading) and more. If your HS or All Star program is successful and does this for you, why not fill up your open time with another activity? Don't we want to encourage kids to be involved so long as they are not overloading their plate? I'll give one example here, Elisa Sabes. Four year All Star with Motions and spent her entire HS career cheering for her HS as well, not to mention being involved in other sports and activities. To this day I still have her 4.0 report card pinned on my wall.

Going back to cheergyms.com, we are doing all we can to provide a service for everyone. Our new "All Star Lite" program is perfect for those who want to put their school cheer first as the commitment level in All Star Lite is less and not as strict. However, it is very possible for kids to commit to a full year program as well and still keep their commitments to their HS.

Nelson de Dios
Motions Cheerleading Gym


__________________
AMEN!!!

Date:


Nelson wrote:
Perhaps I am stepping over the line here and I hope that I do not bruise any ego's, for it is not my intention. But, if I had a child I could not imagine anyone telling my child what they can and cannot do when it comes to their extra curricular activities. What right do they have?


AMEN!!!! Nelson.

__________________
Wondering Wendy

Date:

Ya, I'd love to get a lawyers opinion on this one.

If a High School Cheerleading program allows their members to participate in Club soccer, Club Lacross, Piano Lessons, and outside scholastic tutoring......then why not All Star cheerleading as long as it doesn't interfere?

Maybe there's a great explanation but I'm at a loss. Especially when Pyramids has a program designed SPECIFICALLY to avois this very problem.

__________________
high school cheer HELP!

Date:

I live in Novato and my high school coach hates all-star cheerleading. I want to do both but she told me that I can never come back if I do. The coah is also the director for SM pop warner and she threatens the little pop warner cheerleaders that if they leave they can never come back. It's sad! I want to do high school because I love cheering for my school but colleges look at all-satr cheerleading a lot better then high school. I told my mom about the coach but my coach told us in the beg. of the year that if my mom calls her house to complain that we should just get off the squad. HELP! I've complained to the school but shes been there too long. Another person told me that maybe I need to seek another coach for help because she shouldn't be threatening us! HELP!

__________________
So Cal (OC) Way

Date:

Well, it's funny that this subject be brought up. We were just dealing with this in April. OC All Stars has a program similar to the one cheergyms has. Our gym also runs the program at the high school here but not all of the local schools. My daughter is on both her HS team and her All Star team because the coaches are one in the same. There isn't a scheduling conflict. But one local school does not allow their kids to do both. And this school even practices in our gym!

Now, even though it would be nice to allow the girls to do both, this one school doesn't want to be a part of that plan. So many of our girls had to choose one or the other. But the good thing is, these girls still practice on spring floors because they use the gym. The coaches of the school and our gym work hand in hand also. They just aren't permited to do both.

As my daughter grew up, I always told her she would never cheer in school because I didn't want her risking her All Star years to tumble on grass or the track and get injured. There was no way. But now that OC is also doing Mission Viejo HS, this has proven to be a blessing. MVHS also has seperate cheer teams for games and a competition team made up of girls who want to compete. My daughter chose to only do the games so she could have the "high school" experience and compete at OC. It's wonderful!!! So many choices!

So it CAN work out. We are lucky that the HS she goes to has a program called ECore where you have a laptop and it is linked to the school and the teachers. Your work is done this way. My daughter will be able to do her homework at the gym in between practices or at competitions where she might miss school. What a blessing. And she still has time to have fun!!!!

OC Mom



__________________
Cheerleading Fan

Date:


Wondering Wendy wrote:

Ya, I'd love to get a lawyers opinion on this one.

If a High School Cheerleading program allows their members to participate in Club soccer, Club Lacross, Piano Lessons, and outside scholastic tutoring......then why not All Star cheerleading as long as it doesn't interfere?

Maybe there's a great explanation but I'm at a loss. Especially when Pyramids has a program designed SPECIFICALLY to avois this very problem.




I heard there are people in the industry that are traveling the country to try and stop this act. I think the demand for not being on an all star team is coming from the schools and not all stars. Most all star teams are usually OK with kids being late as long as they come. Traditionally most teams meet 2 times a week for All-Stars which leaves 5 days for h.s. teams. Most high schools meet after school from 3:30-5:30, so if they are on a senior team there is time to practice there as well. To be honest only 27% of the schools in the country compete, so that shouldn't even be an issue with competitive schools. I feel high school coaches/advisors have no real reason, but might of had a bad case where a girl missed a game and the coach was upset. How many kids on h.s. teams miss practices or games, for reasons that aren't even legitimate, let alone the REAL excuses. I agree with Nelson on who is any individual or institution, to NOT let kids participate. The gyms should really get together to STOP this type of roadblocking. I feel if you honor your commitment to BOTH groups and attend everything within reason, then you shold be allowed. I have coached h.s. teams and let kids miss for school plays, dance shows, choir trips, band festivals, and other things. Why is All-star cheer any different?

__________________
...

Date:

Its kind of stupid actualy...my highschool prohibits geting better coaching and faster progress of an allstar program also...its almost like the highschools dont wanna have skill on their teams

__________________
Cheer Mom

Date:

I am amazed at the different responses to this dilemma! It is interesting to see how many high schools are so threatened by allstar cheer. I really don't get it. I do understand not wanting to say it is ok for someone to do another program that would require them to miss or constantly leave practice early as that would be detrimental to the team and vise versa for allstar programs, but if the practices and schedules don't conflict, then what is the problem? I would think they would want the girls with better skills to better their own program because it is natural that girls that see other people throw amazing skills will want to strive to be as good as that and it motivates them to work harder. What benefit is there to pushing the girls with the great skills away from their own school?

__________________
Bay Area Coach

Date:

Well I can see why they would be threatened. It varies depending on the area, but in most cases in California, all-star teams blow high school teams out of the water skill-wise. How can a high school coach keep from losing a kid who does both AS and HS at the same time to AS the following season? Easy - don't let them do AS.

Now, if it were MY kid, I agree with Nelson. No HS coach is going to tell my kid she can't do AS. I'd be more apt to let her do AS instead!

__________________
Yes and No

Date:

Down in So Cal, the HS girls are just as good as the All Stars girls (almost) but that's cause alot of them are also on All Star teams.

GO MISSION VIEJO HIGH SCHOOL

__________________
Who

Date:

Who is the best High School Coed team in California?

__________________
nor cal

Date:

for nor cal oakmont is bombb

__________________
NorCAl High school Coach

Date:

Coming from the other side of cheer. Hs coaches in the bay area only have problems with allstar programs when they interfere with school events, games or summer practices. High school cheer does compete also and I think the problem coaches have at this level are kids just doing the game program and not wanting to compete for our high school but want to compete allstar. At least in our situation, We would love if our kids would do both allstar and high school competitive cheer it would benefit both programs. The problem high schools have is even though allstar gyms say it won't interfere, In the past weve had girls not show up at games and important school events and that makes the District and administration make rules for kids not to participate in both. There is no right or wrong decision in this matter, but just another point of view. I think the lite program is great for people in these situations, I just hope your right and it does not interfere at any level thats when kids get taken off by ADMINISTRATION or by their allstar gym. Usually this is not only a coaches decision.

__________________
Marlon

Date:

I think that if a cheerleader for all stars wants to cheer for high school, they need to realize what they are sacrificing. I know most all star coaches support the high schools, because most of us coach high school teams. CHEERGYMS.COM now offers "All Star Light" teams which would be a GREAT place for Youth football/middle school/high school cheerleaders to compete as an all star. You practice once a week and you dont have to commit yourself to as many things as you would a FULL year program. I think it would benefit high schools as well. It would give them proper training, and give the cheerleaders that extra drive to want to compete on their high school's competition squad. I know our gyms, especially PYRAMIDS, are looking for more all star light cheerleaders, and have A LOT of room for more people. If you are interested i suggest you contact the gym or stop by and get a handbook. :)

Marlon Biete
PYRAMIDS and College Park HS coach

__________________
1 2  >  Last»  | Page of 2  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard